Cope, E. D.

1869.

[Remarks on Holops brevispinus, Ornithotarsus immanis, and Macrosaurus proriger.]

Proceedings of the Academy of Natural Sciences of  Philadelphia, 11(81):123

Meeting of June 1, 1869

Copyright © 2005-2014 by Mike Everhart

Original ePage created February, 2005

Last updated  01/15/2014

 

LEFT: A colorized drawing of the muzzle of the type specimen of Tylosaurus proriger from Cope, 1870, pl. 12, figs. 22, 23.


According to Cope (1875, p. 166), the type specimen of Tylosaurus proriger (Harvard MCZ 4374) was discovered near Monument Rocks in Logan County by "Col. Connyngham [sic] and Mr. Minor," and was shipped by Professor Louis Agassiz following his 1868 visit to western  Kansas (Cope, 1869, 1870, 1875; Williston, 1898; Russell, 1967; Everhart, 2005). It was the first mosasaur to be described from  Kansas and was originally named “Macrosaurus” proriger by Cope.

EDITOR'S NOTE: For the record, Cope mis-spelled the name of the person who discovered Tylosaurus proriger. His full name was John Butler Conyngham (1827-1871), an Army Captain, commanding Company I of the 38th Infantry Regiment at the time of the discovery. Conyngham was a practicing attorney in Wilkes-Barre, Pennsylvania when he joined the Army at the start of the Civil War.  He attained the rank of Brevet Colonel in 1865 while in command of the 52nd Regiment of Pennsylvania Volunteers, and served as the commander until the unit was mustered out in July 1865. 

After the war, he rejoined the Army, was appointed a Captain in the 38th U.S. Infantry Regiment and then was assigned to Kansas.  He assumed military command of "Fort Monument," a stagecoach station along the Butterfield Overland Trail in August, 1867, and on orders from the Army, he moved his troops 35 miles northwest to Antelope Station (now Monument, Kansas) on the Union Pacific Railroad on June 24, 1868. While serving with the 38th Infantry at Fort Clark, Texas, he contracted Bright's disease [kidney failure] and returned to the family home in Pennsylvania.  He died on May 27, 1871 in Wilkes-Barre, Pennsylvania and is buried there.

FIND A GRAVE MEMORIAL TO COL. JOHN BUTLER CONYNGHAM

During the summer of 1868, Louis Agassiz traveled through the Great Plains, including Kansas, with  a group of businessmen and congressmen. While crossing through Kansas on the Union Pacific Railroad, he may have met Capt. Conyngham who was then stationed in the town of Monument, Kansas. It is likely that Conyngham showed the fossil specimen to Agassiz and then arranged to send it to him at Harvard. Cope then saw the specimen at Harvard, then briefly described and named it orally at the June 1, 1869 meeting of the ANSP. 

LEFT: Colonel John Butler Conyngham, Commander, 52nd Regiment, Pennsylvania Volunteers, 1862-1865.

RIGHT: Sketch of  the only wooden building at Fort Monument as drawn by Pvt. J. Stadler, 5th Infantry Regiment. It served as the headquarters for the Army, and living quarters and eating area for the stage company employees and passengers. The troops lived in dug-outs shown in the foreground. (adapted from Lee, 1980). The fort was located a little south and about a mile west of Monument Rocks, on the north side the Smoky Hill River.

The original description of the new species was made orally by Cope at the June 1, 1869 meeting of the Academy of Natural Sciences of Philadelphia (ANSP) and transcribed into the Proceedings,. It was extremely brief by modern standards (below).

 

                                        Natural Sciences of Philadelphia                               123

 

June 1st,

The President, Dr. Hays, in the Chair.

Twenty-one members present.

 

            “Prof. Cope exhibited some specimens of extinct reptiles of interest. …”

……………..

             “He made some remarks on a fine fragment of the muzzle of a large Mosasauroid, which pertained to a cranium of near five feet in length. The pterygoid bones were separated from each other, and support nine teeth. A peculiarity of physiognomy was produced by the cylindric prolongation of the premaxillary bone beyond the teeth, and a similar flat prolongation of the extremity of the dentary. He referred the species to Macrosaurus Owen, under the name M. proriger. The specimen he stated belonged to Prof. Agassiz, who obtained it from Western Kansas, probably from the No. 3 of the Upper Cretaceous [Niobrara Fm.] of Hayden.”


Naming the first mosasaur from Kansas 

The species name (Macrosaurus” proriger) was referred to by Joseph Leidy in the Proceedings of the ANSP on January 4 and January 11, 1870.

Cope (1870, pl. 12, figs 22, 23) described the same specimen more completely, figured it and, with little explanation, referred it to another European genus, Liodon Owen. Two years later, O.C. Marsh, apparently recognizing significant differences between the American and European mosasaurs, proposed a new genus (Rhinosaurus: meaning nose-lizard) from a more complete specimen (YPM 1268 - Rhinosaurus micromus) he had collected ‘on the south side of the Smoky Hill River’ in 1871. However, that name was preoccupied and Cope (1872) proposed the genus name Rhamphosaurus. In a brief note, Marsh (1872, p. 147) wrote that:

“As this name [Rhinosaurus] proves to be preoccupied, it may be replaced with Tylosaurus. The name Rhamphosaurus, since suggested by Prof. Cope, cannot be retained, as it was given to a genus of lizards in 1843 by Fitzinger.” Leidy (1873, p. 274) was the first to placeMacrosaurus’ proriger Cope, 1869 into Tylosaurus Marsh.

That said, Cope didn't give up.... In Cope's "Review of the Vertebrata" paper (1874, p. 36), he wrote this disclaimer as part of his description of a new species, Rhamphosaurus (Tylosaurus) nepaeolicus: "This name was applied by Fitzinger to two species of lizards, which had already received several generic names, and hence became at once a synonym. Further, he did not characterize it; for these reasons the name was not preoccupied at the time I employed it as above; hence there is no necessity for Prof. Marsh's subsequent name Tylosaurus, given on the supposition of preoccupation."

However, Marsh's name was accepted. A third species from the Smoky Hill Chalk (Tylosaurus kansasensis) was named by Everhart (2005).  Several other tylosaurine mosasaurs have been described from around the world, including Antarctica.  


References:

Cope, E.D. 1869. [Remarks on Holops brevispinus, Ornithotarsus immanis, and Macrosaurus proriger.] Proceedings of the Academy of Natural Sciences of  Philadelphia, 11(81):123 (meeting of June 1, 1869)

Cope, E.D. 1869. [Report of the June 1, 1869 meeting of the Academy of Natural Sciences of Philadelphia - Cope report on Cretaceous reptiles of New Jersey]. Nature, 1:121-122.

Cope, E.D. 1870. Synopsis of the extinct Batrachia and Reptilia of North America. Transactions American Philosophical Society, (n. s.) 14:1-252 + i-viii, 55 figs., 14 pl. (*Revision of Cope, 1869, same title, with publication dated listed as August, 1869, published after March, 1870)

Cope, E.D.  1872. [On the structure of the Pythonomorpha]. Proceedings of the Academy of Natural Sciences of Philadelphia 24:140-141. (meeting of June 11)

Cope, E.D. 1875. The Vertebrata of the Cretaceous formations of the West. Report, U. S. Geological Survey Territories (Hayden). 2:302 p, 57 pls.

Everhart, M.J. 2005. Oceans of Kansas - A Natural History of the Western Interior Sea. Indiana University Press, 322 pp.

Lee, W.C. 1980. Trails of the Smoky Hill. Caxton Press, Caldwell, Idaho, 235 pp., 2nd Printing (2008).

Leidy, J. 1870. Comments on Fossils, Jan. 4 meeting. Proceedings of the Academy of Natural Sciences of Philadelphia 22:1-3.  

Leidy, J. 1870. Comments on Fossils, Jan. 11 meeting. Proceedings of the Academy of Natural Sciences of Philadelphia 22:3-5.

Leidy, J. 1873. Contributions to the extinct vertebrate fauna of the western interior territories. Rept., U.S. Geological Survey Territories (Hayden) 1:358 pp., 37 pls.

Marsh, O. C. 1872. Note on Rhinosaurus. American Journal of Science 4(20):147. 

Russell, D.A. 1967. Systematics and morphology of American mosasaurs. Peabody Museum of Natural History, Yale University Bulletin 23, 241 pp.

Wetzel, C.R. 1960. Monument Station, Gove County. The Kansas Historical Quarterly 26:250-254.  LINK

Williston, S.W. 1898. Mosasaurs. The University Geological Survey of Kansas, Part V. 4:81-347, pls. 10-72.