tylo000.jpg (90690 bytes)

 

 

Tylosaurus proriger

A new record of a large mosasaur from the Smoky Hill Chalk

Copyright 2000-2011 by Mike Everhart

Last updated 06/15/2011

 

 

LEFT: The skull of the Tylosaurus proriger (FFHM 1997-10). The measuring stick is one meter in length (39.37 inches).  The skull is 49 inches long.

Things are often more complicated than they may appear.  I became involved in the recovery of this specimen after the landowner discovered that it was being collected without his permission.  It was a sticky situation and feelings were hurt in the process. Parts (the front limbs) are missing and probably beyond recovery. A friend of mine was involved as a volunteer in the dig, assuming that landowner permission had been obtained, and provides the story of the initial stages of the dig on his website.

In September, 1996, we removed the skull and seven cervical vertebrae of a very large mosasaur from an exposure of the Smoky Hill chalk called Horse Thief Canyon, south of Quinter, in Gove County, Kansas. The locality was near the site of Sternberg’s famous "fish-in-a-fish" (Xiphactinus audax) specimen and was from about the middle of the Smoky Hill Chalk member (middle Santonian age, Late Cretaceous) of the Niobrara formation. The remains are approximately 85 million years old.  The picture at the top of this page shows the the right side of the skull and cervical vertebrae as viewed in the field. Apparently, the skull came to rest in an an upright position before slumping over on the left side. The right lower jaw came apart prior to fossilization. The right quadrate and part of the right rear of the skull are visible above the skull. Ribs and bones from the front limbs were also found in this area, including several limb elements that were within the skull itself.

The skull was 4 ft. (1.2 m) in length and was found laying on its left side. It was crushed laterally. Except for portions of the right lower jaw, the right quadrate, and the right and left pterygoid bones that make up the hard palate in the roof of the mouth, however, the skull was still articulated, and in excellent condition. The vertebrae of the neck were still articulated and attached to the occipital condyle at the base of the skull. Several ribs and limb bones were also recovered at the site.

Based on the size of the skull, the entire animal would have been about 30 ft. (9+ m) in length. Evidence from the site indicated that at least some of the rest of the specimen (20 ft.) might still be in place. From the size of the animal, it was almost certain that it was a Tylosaurus, but the species was not positively determined in the field. Tylosaurs are the largest of the three genera of mosasaurs commonly found in the chalk, but supposedly only reached this size in the upper portions of the Smoky Hill chalk. Many complete or nearly complete specimens of this species from Kansas are in major museums around the world thanks to the efforts of early paleontologists such as Cope, Marsh, and Sternberg.

Naming the first mosasaur from Kansas  

As a bit of historical background, the type specimen of Tylosaurus proriger (MCZ 4374) was discovered near Monument Rocks in Gove County by "Col. Connyngham and Mr. Minor," and was obtained by Professor Louis Agassiz during his 1868 visit to western Kansas. It was the first mosasaur to be described from Kansas and was originally named “Macrosaurus” proriger by E. D. Cope. The description of the new species by Cope (1869) in the minutes of the Academy of Natural Sciences of Philadelphia meeting of June 1 was brief by modern standards:

He [Cope] made some remarks on a fine fragment of the muzzle of a large Mosasauroid, which pertained to a cranium of near five feet in length. The pterygoid bones were separated from each other, and support nine teeth. A peculiarity of physiognomy was produced by the cylindric prolongation of the premaxillary bone beyond the teeth, and a similar flat prolongation of the extremity of the dentary. He referred the species to Macrosaurus Owen, under the name M. proriger.”

The following year, Cope (1870, pl. 12, figs 22, 23) described the same specimen more completely, figured it and, with little explanation, referred it to another European genus, Liodon Owen. Two years later, O.C. Marsh, apparently recognizing significant differences between the American and European mosasaurs, proposed a new genus (Rhinosaurus: meaning nose-lizard) from a more complete specimen (YPM 1268 - Rhinosaurus micromus) he had collected ‘on the south side of the Smoky Hill River’ in 1871. However, that name was preoccupied and Cope (1872) proposed the genus name Rhamphosaurus. In a brief note, Marsh (1872b, p. 147) wrote that:

“As this name [Rhinosaurus] proves to be preoccupied, it may be replaced with Tylosaurus. The name Rhamphosaurus, since suggested by Prof. Cope, cannot be retained, as it was given to a genus of lizards in 1843 by Fitzinger.” Leidy (1873, p. 274) was the first to placeMacrosaurus’ proriger Cope, 1869 into Tylosaurus Marsh.

That said, Cope didn't give up.... In Cope's "Review of the Vertebrata" paper (1874, p. 36), he wrote this disclaimer as part of his description of a new species, Rhamphosaurus (Tylosaurus) nepaeolicus: "This name was applied by Fitzinger to two species of lizards, which had already received several generic names, and hence became at once a synonym. Further, he did not characterize it; for these reasons the name was not preoccupied at the time I employed it as above; hence there is no necessity for Prof. Marsh's subsequent name Tylosaurus, given on the supposition of preoccupation."

However, Marsh's name was accepted. A third species from the Smoky Hill Chalk (Tylosaurus kansasensis) was named by Everhart (2005).  Several other tylosaurine mosasurs have been described from around the world, including Antarctica.  

tylo.jpg (42919 bytes) LEFT: A drawing of the right side of a Tylosaurus proriger skeleton (adapted from Russell, 1967), showing the elements found or accounted for as of September, 1996.

When the skull was turned over to expose the left side, initial preparation showed that the left quadrate was complete and still articulated with the back the skull and the left lower jaw. There were also indications of some soft tissue preservation (cartilage) on the quadrate where the mosasaur's ear drum (tympanum) would have been located. Further prep revealed that the sclerotic ring was intact and in place where the left eye would have been. Apparently this is the first time that this feature has been observed in Tylosaurs. Although one tooth was missing in the premaxilla, all other teeth were present in the left maxilla (upper jaw) and dentary (lower jaw). There are 15 teeth in each upper jaw and 13 in each lower jaw. The teeth are conical in shape and the largest are about 2 inches high with a base that is about 1.5 inches across.

tylo001.jpg (50374 bytes) LEFT: The left side of the skull after final preparation. The dark color is the actual color of the specimen and makes photography difficult! The only coatings used were Superglue (Paleobond) to preserve the teeth. Scale is 6 inches (15 cm).
tylodraw.jpg (47738 bytes) LEFT: A drawing of the left side of the skull after final preparation. Because of distortion due to crushing during preservation, most of the top of the skull (frontal and parietal) are visible along with all the elements of the left side.

As the surrounding chalk matrix was removed, special attention was paid to the characteristics of the quadrate, the joint between the pre-frontal and post-orbital frontal bones over the eye, the location of the nasal opening (located above the suture between the premaxilla and maxilla of the upper jaw), and the location of the parietal foramen on the top of the skull. These are key characteristics in determining species in tylosaurs.

tylo006a.jpg (3513 bytes) This is a lateral view of the left quadrate of the specimen.  Many of the characteristics of this bone are obscured by the preservation of the tympanum (ear drum) in the center. Click here for a drawing of the left quadrate of Tylosaurus proriger (adapted from Russell, 1967).   Additional pictures of this quadrate are shown HERE and HERE.  Although completely at home in the ocean, mosasaurs had evolved from terrestrial lizards and certainly had a sense of hearing.
tylo004a.jpg (5188 bytes) Tylosaurus proriger is the only mosasaur species in which a forward projecting spur of the post-orbital frontal actually overlaps the posterior edge of the pre-frontal bone.  In T. nepaeolicus, the post-orbital frontal and pre-frontal meet over the orbit of the eye, but there is no overlap.  In most other mosasaurs, the post-orbital front and pre-frontal do not touch, and the frontal forms the upper part of the orbit of the eye.
tylo013a.jpg (5313 bytes) The parietal foramen in Tylosaurus proriger is relatively small compared to other mosasaurs and located behind the suture between the frontal and parietal bones. In T. nepaeolicus, the parietal foramen is larger and located several diameters behind the suture.
tylo015a.jpg (4675 bytes) The location of the nares is a distinguishing characteristic between Tylosaurus proriger and T. nepaeolicus.  In most specimens of Tylosaurus proriger, the opening of the external nares begins at a point between the 5th and 6th tooth on the maxilla.  In T. nepaeolicus, the opening is begins above the fifth tooth.    In this specimen, however, the opening of the nares occurs between the fourth maxillary tooth, possibly indicating that this is a transitional form.
tylo003a.jpg (5457 bytes) "Here's looking at you!"......a ring of bony plates (sclerotic ring) that surrounded the left eye of this mosasaur. This is apparently a very rare preservation in Tylosaurus.

Gordon Bell (then at the South Dakota School of Mines) was contacted regarding the identification of the specimen and, after reviewing the information, said that there was no doubt that this was a Tylosaurus proriger. He also indicated that this specimen would be a very early record for the species. A review of data provided by Bruce Schumacher (also then at the School of Mines) on Kansas mosasaurs showed that there are no records of this species in Gove County or from this low in the Smoky Hill Chalk. It appears likely that this specimen is at least one million years older than previously documented finds of Tylosaurus proriger.

tylo008a.jpg (5250 bytes) A view of the mid-portion of the left side of the skull, showing the location of the sclerotic ring. The narrow finger of bone projecting forward over the sclerotic ring is the anterior extension of the post-orbital frontal (POF). This is one of the key characteristics that makes this specimen a Tylosaurus proriger. In most mosasaurs, the POF barely contacts the prefrontal. In some genera, such as Clidastes, the POF and prefrontal are widely separated, and the frontal itself forms a bony ridge over the eye socket. In Tylosaurus proriger, the POF overlaps the prefrontal and may have provided additional strengthening of the skull
tylo014a.jpg (4453 bytes) A close-up view of the anterior extension of the post-orbital frontal over the orbit of the eye.
tylo016a.jpg (4933 bytes) The left exterior nasal opening of the mosasaur's skull. Although well adapted to marine life, mosasaurs were still air breathers and probably breathed through their nasal openings when they surfaced.
tylo017a.jpg (5210 bytes) The business end of a mosasaur, showing the extension of the premaxilla over the most anterior teeth which is also typical of Tylosaurs. The large premaxilla is often assumed to have been used as a 'battering ram' but this appears to be highly unlikely. The joint between the premaxilla and maxilla is shown between the second and third teeth on the upper jaw. Pits shown in the upper and lower jaws are probably openings for blood vessels and nerves.
tylo018a.jpg (5376 bytes) The middle teeth in the upper and lower jaws.  Although shaped like sharp cones, the teeth do not have much of a cutting edge.  In most mosasaurs, the teeth were used primarily for seizing and crushing prey, which was then swallowed whole.
tylo019a.jpg (6437 bytes) The posterior teeth in the upper and lower jaws. 
FFHM1997-10Aa.jpg (18117 bytes) The discovery of the specimen was dramatized in a documentary filmed for the Paleoworld series on the Discovery Channel. Unfortunately, the series was cancelled in mid-season and the documentary was not shown in the United States. It has been shown on various television networks around the world, including the Philippines.

On April 19, 1997, the specimen was donated by the land owners to the Fick Fossil and Historical Museum in Oakley, Kansas where it will be on permanent display. It was later filmed by a movie crew from Australia, but the footage was later cut from the documentary. A photo of me with the specimen is HERE.

On October 11, 1997, the specimen was reported at the 57th annual meeting of the Society of Vertebrate Paleontology in Chicago, IL. The published abstract for that presentation is shown below:

Everhart, M. J. and P. A. Everhart. 1997. Earliest occurrence of the mosasaur, Tylosaurus proriger, (Mosasauridae: Squamata) in the Smoky Hill Chalk (Niobrara Formation, upper Cretaceous) of western Kansas. Jour. Vert. Paleon. 17(Supplement to 3):44A.

In 1996, the articulated skull and seven cervical vertebrae of a large (10 m) mosasaur were collected from the middle of the Smoky Hill Chalk member of the Niobrara Chalk (Upper Cretaceous) in Kansas. Stratigraphically, the remains were found 2.7 m. below the base of Marker Unit 10 and within the upper portion of the biostratigraphic zone of Clioscaphites vermiformis. The site is middle Santonian age and is dated at about 85 mya. The specimen was identified as Tylosaurus proriger on the basis of the following characters: the lateral overlap of the prefrontal by the post-orbital frontal, the large infrastapedial process of the quadrate and the location of the parietal foramen. The length of the skull (1.2 m) was also a key identifying factor since no other mosasaur of this time was as large. The slightly more anterior location of the nares, compared to other specimens of T. proriger, is a condition that is probably transitional from T. nepaeolicus. T. proriger has not been previously reported from lower than Marker Unit 15. This new specimen extends the temporal range of this species in the Western Interior Sea by at least 1.5 million years and further defines the ecological diversity of the seaway during the deposition of the Smoky Hill Chalk.


Samuel W. Williston's Tylosaurus proriger .

Line drawings from Volume IV of the University Geological Survey of Kansas, published 1898

The Dig Continues - New Field Work - May 2-4, 1997

We Finally Complete the Dig......June 28, and August 7-8, 1997


Credits: The drawings of the Tylosaurus proriger skull and skeleton were adapted from Systematics and Morphology of American Mosasaurs, by Dale A. Russell, pgs 173 and 238, Peabody Museum of Natural History, Yale University Bulletin 23, 1967.